Post by @andyc

I am currently watching 'Traitors Canada'. Obviously, I don't know who these reality stars are but God almighty, Kevin just puts the fear of God into me. I just find his appearance, his analysis and behaviour weird. In fact, I find everything about him deeply unsettling.

I just hope @evan@cosocial.ca has watched the show and provide some reassurance to stop these recurring nightmares.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/iplayer/episodes/m002wyzd/the-traitors-canada

Replying to @andyc

@andyc So, I have some thoughts.

First, I got interested in data analysis of Traitors. Everyone seems to want to be a Traitor at the beginning of the show. I think that's mostly bravado, but it made me wonder: is there any advantage to being a Traitor over being a Faithful?

Replying to @evan@cosocial.ca

@andyc Of course, there is a gameplay advantage, but there are detriments too. The Traitors have the advantages of information (they know who everyone is) and unity (they are working towards the same goal, most of the time). But the Faithful have the advantage of numbers (5 or 6 to 1 advantage, usually!) as well as lower anxiety (they don't have to lie as much).

Replying to @evan@cosocial.ca

@andyc Anyway, how does that shake out? In the Anglosphere (UK, US, Australia, NZ, Canada) you have about an 8% chance of winning the game if you start off as a Faithful. But you have about a 15% chance of winning the game if you start off as Traitor! Almost double the chances.

Replying to @evan@cosocial.ca

@andyc What's really interesting is that this varies culturally. In France, the famously most cutthroat and soap operaish game, you have a 30% chance of winning if you start as a Traitor.

Replying to @evan@cosocial.ca

@andyc There are only two shows, from the data I was able to get, where you actually have a statistical advantage if you start as a Faithful.

- The Netherlands
- Quebec

Replying to @evan@cosocial.ca

@andyc I think the key to winning as a Faithful is getting to the point where you can trust other Faithfuls, strategise with them, and then systematically eliminate the Traitors.

I think this takes some level of social cohesion -- you need to be able to trust people by default. And I guess that is easier to do in some cultures than in others.

Replying to @evan@cosocial.ca

@andyc Probably my favourite example is from Traitors Canada FR, season 1. The Faithful had got down to a final 5, with one well-known Traitor. The four Faithful just had to walk through it, and they'd split the money. But one of the Faithful started getting bossy, and tried to cause drama. The other 3 voted off the Traitor -- and then voted him off too! Then they split the money three ways.

Replying to @evan@cosocial.ca

@andyc Anyway, I haven't watched this season of Traitors Canada En, but I'm interested and I'll keep an eye on this Kevin character.

Replying to @evan@cosocial.ca

@evan@cosocial.ca I firmly believe it's better to be a traitor.